Goaltending depth is often a luxury in the NHL, but for the Philadelphia Flyers (who have notably struggled in the goalie department over the years), it’s becoming a double-edged sword. With Sam Ersson looking set to return from injury soon, head coach John Tortorella and the Flyers’ management face a critical decision: how to manage a trio of goaltenders, each of whom has proven they deserve consideration.
While Ersson remains the No. 1 choice in net, both Ivan Fedotov and Aleksei Kolosov have stepped up in his absence, delivering performances that complicate the decision-making process. Kolosov’s quick adaptation to the NHL and Fedotov’s immense strides this season have created an enviable—but difficult—logjam in the Flyers’ crease.
Sam Ersson: The Undisputed Starter
Before getting injured, Sam Ersson had firmly established himself as the Flyers’ top goaltender. His calm demeanor, technical precision, and ability to make timely saves have made him an essential part of Philadelphia’s roster. Even though he’s been sidelined, Tortorella hasn’t wavered on what Ersson’s status is within the team, saying after practice on Monday, “He’s our number one guy.”
At just 24 years old, Ersson represents the ideal balance of youth and maturity that has become a central theme of the Flyers’ rebuild, and has consistently proven that he has the mindset and capabilities of becoming an undeniable NHL starting goalie.
Megan DeRuchie-The Hockey News
Tortorella’s public affirmation that Ersson remains the team’s No. 1 option reflects how much trust the organization has in his ability to lead the team’s defensive efforts. However, reintegrating Ersson into a crowded crease will be far from straightforward, especially given the performances of his replacements and the ongoing evaluation of all three netminders.
“We’re eventually gonna have to figure this out, depending on health, right?” Tortorella said. “We’ve gotta figure out what happens as we push through here. I think [Kolosov and Fedotov] have really stepped in…but we still need to see more as we play more.”
Ivan Fedotov: Proving Doubters Wrong
Fedotov’s journey this season has been nothing short of remarkable. After a tumultuous few games at the end of last season and questions about whether he could adapt to the NHL, the 28-year-old has silenced critics with steady, reliable play. His size, composure under pressure, and ability to track the puck have made him an increasingly dependable option.
While Fedotov may not boast the same athleticism or upside as Ersson, he’s delivered several standout performances that have kept the Flyers alive in games, showcasing the work he’s been putting in to be the best version of himself. It’s important to note how much Fedotov’s game has matured: he’s become more assertive in challenging shooters and reading plays—significant strides for a goaltender once seen as more of a placeholder than a long-term solution.
Fedotov’s performance has greatly bolstered the argument for him as an NHL goalie, and it certainly helps that the Flyers went into this season with their hearts set on an Ersson/Fedotov tandem.
Aleksei Kolosov: The Wild Card With Potential
Perhaps the most intriguing factor in this equation is Aleksei Kolosov. The 22-year-old Belarusian netminder entered the season as an unproven commodity at the NHL level, but has made quite the case for himself in Ersson’s absence. His athleticism, quick reflexes, and confident positioning have caught the attention of fans and coaches alike.
However, Kolosov’s exhaustively-documented journey to North America brings its own complications. It raises questions about how the Flyers can accommodate him without stunting his development—Kolosov is still young, and there are still many aspects of his game that need refinement. While he’s performed admirably in his starts, it’s debatable whether Kolosov has truly leapfrogged Fedotov for the backup tole or whether his upside alone makes him worth keeping on the NHL roster.
Related: Flyers Give More Insight Into Kolosov Saga
The Options Ahead
The most conventional (and likely) approach would be to reinstate Ersson as the clear-cut starter, with Fedotov as his backup. This scenario prioritizes stability and allows Kolosov to continue honing his skills in the AHL, where he can get consistent starts without the pressure of an NHL workload.
However, this decision does risk alienating Kolosov, especially if he feels he’s earned a bigger role. It also leaves little room for experimentation or rewarding performance, potentially stifling Fedotov’s momentum.
If the Flyers are feeling bold, however, they could adopt the more fluid approach of rotating Ersson, Fedotov, and Kolosov based on performance and matchups. While this would provide opportunities for all three goaltenders to showcase their abilities and get ample rest time between starts, it risks disrupting rhythm and chemistry, especially for Ersson as he works to regain his form post-injury and learns how to handle the workload of an NHL starting goalie.
Megan DeRuchie-The Hockey News
(Not to mention, this option also complicates the Flyers’ roster management, as carrying three goaltenders long-term is rarely sustainable.)
For now, the Flyers have a luxury of solid options for the first time in a long time, but as Tortorella has repeatedly emphasized, decisions will be made based on merit and the team’s best interests. Whether that means leaning on Ersson as the clear starter, rewarding Fedotov’s steady progress, or finding a way to keep Kolosov engaged and developing, the Flyers’ goaltending situation will be one of the most fascinating storylines to watch as the season unfolds.
Related: Four Flyers Prospects Make Team Canada Camp
